Here’s What Makes Truck Accident Claims More Complex

July 5, 2025

If you’ve been involved in a truck accident, you’re dealing with a much more complicated legal and insurance landscape than if it was just a standard car accident. At first glance, it might feel like any other crash: two vehicles, some damage, and a handful of phone calls. But once you peel back the layers, you’ll quickly realize that truck accident claims operate in an entirely different league.

Truck accidents come with more variables, more parties, and far more regulations. And if you’re not careful, those factors can be used against you to delay your compensation or reduce your rightful claim. Understanding what makes these cases so different is the first step in protecting yourself.

Multiple Parties Are Often Involved

In a typical car accident, it’s usually just two drivers and two insurance companies. But truck accidents rarely follow that simple script.

You might be dealing with the truck driver, the trucking company, a third-party maintenance provider, a parts manufacturer, or even a shipping company. Each of them may carry their own insurance policies and legal representation (and each will try to deflect responsibility onto someone else).

You can imagine how complicated this gets. You’re no longer just proving someone was at fault. You’re now tasked with navigating a web of finger-pointing, all while trying to recover from the aftermath of a scary crash.

Federal Regulations Change the Rules

Truck drivers and trucking companies aren’t just subject to state traffic laws. They’re held to a strict set of federal regulations laid out by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA). These rules govern everything from how many hours a driver can operate without rest to how much weight a truck can legally haul.

“Truck accidents differ from other motor vehicle accidents in several ways,” Mette Attorneys at Law explains. “There are numerous federal regulations that, for the safety of everyone on the road, require strict adherence to various aspects, including the weight of the truck and the maximum time the driver can operate on the road. Also, due to their size and weight, truck accidents have a disproportionate ability to render serious injuries and death when compared to other types of accidents.”

In other words, we’re not just looking at who was speeding or ran a red light. This is about whether the driver exceeded their hours of service, and whether the brakes were inspected or the load was secured properly.

The Damage Is Usually More Severe

There’s a reason truck accident claims are often higher in value than typical car accident claims: the injuries are usually far worse.

A fully loaded semi-truck can weigh up to 80,000 pounds. That kind of force rarely results in a fender bender. It almost always causes catastrophic injuries and, in some cases, fatalities. As a result, the medical bills are higher, the recovery takes longer, and the emotional toll is staggering.

Because of that, trucking companies and their insurers are under pressure to limit payouts. This is why they often respond aggressively, sending investigators to the scene quickly, digging into your background, and even questioning the severity of your injuries.

You need to be ready for that level of resistance (and it’s one of the reasons why hiring a lawyer with truck accident experience is so critical).

The Evidence You Need Is Technical and Time-Sensitive

Truck accident investigations usually involve a lot of different types of evidence that aren’t present in your typical motor vehicle accident. For example:

  • Electronic logging devices (ELDs) that track driver hours
  • Black box data that records speed, braking, and other critical info
  • Maintenance and inspection records
  • Driver logs and drug test results
  • Load manifests and weight tickets

Much of this evidence is controlled by the trucking company, and if it’s not preserved quickly, it can be lost or intentionally destroyed. That’s why time is of the essence. The sooner you take legal action, the better your chances of securing the documentation that proves negligence.

Insurance Policies Are Massive

Commercial trucking companies are required to carry far more insurance than individual drivers. Some policies run into the millions. On one hand, that’s good news. It means there’s more potential compensation available for serious injuries. But on the other hand, it means insurance adjusters have more incentive to fight. They’ll use every legal tactic to minimize your claim, delay the process, or try to shift the blame.

Don’t be surprised if insurance companies request recorded statements or push you to settle early, before the full extent of your injuries is even known.

Legal Representation Is a Game-Changer

Truck accident claims are too complex to handle all alone. The companies you’re up against have teams of lawyers and years of experience reducing payouts. If you try to handle things on your own, you’re stepping into a gunfight with a butter knife.

A personal injury attorney who specializes in truck accidents will know how to:

  • Investigate the scene
  • Preserve key evidence before it disappears
  • Navigate federal regulations
  • Calculate the full cost of your injuries and losses
  • Hold all responsible parties accountable

Most importantly, an attorney can handle the legal stress so you can focus on recovery. This frees you up from unnecessary anxiety or worry.

Pushing Forward for Recovery

Recovery after a car accident is admittedly complicated. Trying to recover after a truck accident is even more complex and involved than most people realize from the outside looking in. The more familiar you are with the details, the less friction there will be.

You may also like